Wednesday, November 30, 2005

Things that make you go Hmmm......

So - I had an interesting conversation today....the details of which aren't all that important except that this person - Deep Throat (for the purposes of this post) - basically said that he/she would be more offended by a racist remark than a homophobic remark.

So I was thinking about this, and since I can't be wholly objective - I'm curious what people think?

Are racism and homophobia equally deplorable...or is one more acceptable than the other? As a baseline I realize that neither are acceptable, so were talking about them in relation to one another.

There seems to be a mutually overarching intolerance concern, but apart from that there are differences between the types of bigotry....e.g. relative status of the affected groups, social integration, social acceptance, statutory discrimination, economic and educational opportunities, incidence of violent hate-based crimes, etc..... So maybe these differences justify the statement "Racism is worse than Homophobia" - I don't know.....I tend to think that they're equally deplorable and that placing Homophobia second to Racism will continue to relegated the GLBT population to second-class citizenship, even w/r/to their quest for civil rights, but there are other arguments to be made.

Thoughts/Comments?????

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

hmmm... i'm posting because i feel that i've been misrepresented. i didn't say that i would be more offended by a racist remark than i would be by a homophobic remark.

the question that was posed to me was whether i would take as much offense to a homophobic remark as AML would. and i think that obviously i would not. the stakes are different. would i take offense to a homophobic remark? absolutely! would i take offense to a racist remark? absolutely! and for the same reasons. but what i thought we were discussing is whether homophobic remarks affected me and AML in the same way. undeniably they do not. but that doesn't mean that i condone homophobic comments in any way...

12/02/2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

simply put: they are equally bad. dra

12/03/2005  

Post a Comment

<< Home